Echo Journey™
Back to Insights

Insight ·

I Was Rated 4.7 out of 5 on BetterHelp. I Left Anyway

My BetterHelp sessions averaged 4.7 out of 5 from 1,436 responses. Why I still left in 2026, and what that means for you when choosing a therapist.

A therapist can be rated highly and still be running on empty. My sessions averaged 4.7 out of 5, and I left anyway, because high ratings did not protect me from burnout. For you as a client, what protects your therapy is a therapist with a sustainable workload who can stay with you over time.

I am Hendrina Sterling Rodríguez, a bilingual psychotherapist working in English and Spanish. Until 2026 I also worked on BetterHelp, the largest online therapy platform. I have now left it to focus on my private practice, and what follows is my own experience, shared openly with my own figures.

What did my BetterHelp ratings show?

In my experience, numbers tell only part of a story, so I am showing all of them, including the lowest. These are the aggregate figures from my own BetterHelp therapist dashboard; they contain no client information.

Live session rating by monthBar chart of my average live session rating by month, out of 5: Nov 2025 4.9, Dec 2025 4.9, Jan 2026 4.4, Feb 2026 4.7, Mar 2026 4.5, Apr 2026 4.7, May 2026 4.8, Jun 2026 4.8, Jul 2026 4.9, Aug 2026 4.6, Sep 2026 5.0. Overall 4.7 from 1,436 responses.0123454.9Nov254.9Dec254.4Jan264.7Feb264.5Mar264.7Apr264.8May264.8Jun264.9Jul264.6Aug265.0Sep26
Live session rating by month (out of 5)
MonthRating
Nov 20254.9
Dec 20254.9
Jan 20264.4
Feb 20264.7
Mar 20264.5
Apr 20264.7
May 20264.8
Jun 20264.8
Jul 20264.9
Aug 20264.6
Sep 20265.0
Therapy quality ratings (all of them)Horizontal bar chart of all my therapy quality ratings, out of 5: Client recommendation 3.8 (871 responses), Communication variety 4.3 (662 responses), Timely responses 4.3 (717 responses), Respect and support 4.3 (698 responses), Empathy 4.2 (679 responses), Expertise 4.2 (661 responses).Client recommendation3.8(871)Communication variety4.3(662)Timely responses4.3(717)Respect and support4.3(698)Empathy4.2(679)Expertise4.2(661)
Therapy quality ratings, all of them (out of 5)
AreaRatingResponses
Client recommendation3.8871
Communication variety4.3662
Timely responses4.3717
Respect and support4.3698
Empathy4.2679
Expertise4.2661
Dashboard totals
FigureValue
Overall live session rating4.7 (1,436 responses)
Total live sessions4,713
Reported no-shows1%
Late cancellations2%
Clients helped since 2024711
Source: my BetterHelp therapist dashboard, Nov 2025 - Sep 2026.

Overall, my live sessions were rated 4.7 out of 5 from 1,436 responses, across 4,713 live sessions, with reported no-shows of 1% and late cancellations of 2%. I have helped 711 clients since 2024. The lowest figure, 3.8 out of 5 for client recommendation, is there too, because the whole picture matters more than the flattering part.

Why did I leave anyway?

In my experience, I went through burnout several times without support. I reduced my caseload, but I was still working as hard for less. Eventually I took a week off to recover, because I could feel that tiredness was beginning to cost the people in front of me. In my case, burnout, largely from the workload I carried, was a major reason I left the UK two years ago.

What happened in 2026?

In my experience, these things happened over the same months. In March 2026 I received a clinical quality message saying my account had been flagged for responsiveness and for reported no-shows. My reported no-shows were 1% of sessions as shown on my dashboard (41 client-reported no-shows out of 4,713 sessions). Later my account was restricted from receiving new client referrals. I asked for clarification and received an explanation based on performance metrics and client feedback. My live-session rating was 4.7 out of 5 across 1,436 responses and my quality ratings were all above 4 out of 5 (client recommendation 3.8). In my opinion, differences of a few tenths of a point should not be what limits a therapist’s referrals, and I decided to focus on my private clients.

What does this mean for you as a client?

Ratings capture how sessions felt, not whether your therapist can keep going. A therapist can be warm, skilled and well rated while carrying a workload that is quietly wearing them down, and in my experience that is when continuity is most at risk. Before you choose, it can help to ask:

  • How many people do you see in a typical week, and how do you protect time to rest?
  • Will I see you every week, and do you expect to keep working with me over the coming months?
  • What happens if you need time off: will we plan it together?
  • How do you handle it if I feel something is not working between us?

How I work now

In my private practice I keep a caseload that lets me give each person full attention, the same therapist every week, and a short follow-up note after sessions when it helps. If you want one therapist who stays with you, in English or Spanish: Book a first conversation. You can also explore other practitioners in the Echo practitioner directory, or read the guide to burnout.

Adding my voice

I am adding my voice to therapists who have spoken publicly about feeling undervalued by the platform model and its advertising, as reported by Welldoing (its reporting on the London Underground adverts and its reporting on UK therapists’ workload and pay). This is my experience, and I believe clients deserve therapists who are valued, rested and able to stay.

This article reflects my personal professional experience and opinions. It is not a review of, or a statement of fact about, any company.

Echo Journey is independent and not affiliated with BetterHelp or ReGain.

Where to take this next

Explore Managing Anxiety & Panic Attacks for working through anxiety and panic with CBT tools

A therapist-led video course and CBT journal for anxiety, panic and nervous system calm.

Explore Managing Anxiety & Panic Attacks – Video Course + CBT Journal

This is Echo's own course, created by Hendrina Sterling Rodriguez.

Suggested resource: Psychology of Seduction

Psychology of Seduction: Unveiling the Art of Influence and Empowerment — an exploration of the psychology underpinning influence, self-confidence and relationships.

View Psychology of Seduction

As an Amazon Associate, Echo Journey earns from qualifying purchases made through this link, at no extra cost to you.

Questions to sit with

Ask yourself, gently and without needing an answer straight away:

  • What do therapist ratings tell you, and what do you feel they leave unseen?
  • What does having the same therapist over time mean to you?
  • How would you want to talk with a therapist when something between you feels difficult or isn't working?

Continue exploring

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

The questions readers most often bring to this topic, answered in short.

Why would a therapist leave with ratings that high?

In my experience, ratings measured how sessions felt to clients, not whether my workload was sustainable. I went through burnout several times without support, my account was later restricted from new client referrals, and when I asked for clarification I received an explanation based on performance metrics and client feedback. In my opinion, differences of a few tenths of a point should not be what limits a therapist’s referrals, so I left to focus on private clients.

Where do these BetterHelp figures come from?

In my experience as a therapist there until 2026, these are the aggregate figures from my own BetterHelp therapist dashboard, from November 2025 to September 2026. They contain no client information, and I show all of them, including the lowest.

What happened after the clinical quality message?

In my experience, the message said my account had been flagged for responsiveness and reported no-shows. My reported no-shows were 1% of sessions as shown on my dashboard (41 client-reported no-shows out of 4,713 sessions). I asked for clarification and received an explanation based on performance metrics and client feedback. My live-session rating was 4.7 out of 5 across 1,436 responses and my quality ratings were all above 4 out of 5 (client recommendation 3.8). In my opinion, differences of a few tenths of a point should not be what limits a therapist’s referrals, and I decided to focus on my private clients.

What should I ask a therapist about their workload?

Ask how many people they see in a typical week, how they protect time to rest, and whether they expect to keep working with you over the coming months. In my experience, a therapist who can answer those openly is more likely to offer you continuity.

Sources

  1. Flückiger et al. (2018), The alliance in adult psychotherapy: a meta-analytic synthesis — Tier 1
  2. NIMH — Psychotherapies — Tier 1
  3. Work with Hendrina — Tier 2

Stay in touch

Want more like this?

We'll send you the occasional email with things that might help. No pressure — unsubscribe whenever.

Written by Hendrina Sterling Rodríguez, psychotherapist and founder of Echo Journey. If you’d like to work with me directly, book a consultation.

Reflect on what you just read

Echo Journey is a quiet place to notice patterns, soften self-criticism, and choose your next small step.